Facets of Ladakhi Society, Economy and its Monastic Establishment in the Medieval period
Rinchen Dolma
Ph.D. Student, Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU), New Delhi, India.
*Corresponding Author E-mail: rinchendolma.12@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
This work is an attempt to look into the social and economic structure of medieval Ladakh. Ladakh in the medieval times was well connected to its neighbours through the network of trade routes. These routes provided a means for the movement of people, and helped in the cultural, material and economic exchanges. The structure of the Ladakhi society was hierarchical and it was reflected in the title of address and reference and also from the order of sitting in the social gathering. The monasteries also had a great impact on the life of the people as monks had to be engaged in every sphere of life. Monasteries also influenced the economy of the region as they were the major landholder. The pattern of the household system in Ladakhi society is related to the taxation system and the ownership of the land. The economy of medieval Ladakh depended on the combination of agriculture, pastoralism and trade.
KEYWORDS: Ladakh, Monastery, Society, Economy, Taxation.
INTRODUCTION:
Ladakh has been referred to as Western Tibet by early Western writers and as Greater Tibet by Oriental scholars. Many writers and travelers have described Ladakh with different names and adjectives. Moonland, Little Tibet, Great Tibet, Roof of the world, Maryul, Mangyul, Kiecha, Land of High passes, Land of Lamas and many more. Cunningham writes that the name Ladakh is a corruption of the original Tibetan form La-Tags, but it is also called Maryul1, or Low land or Red land, and Khachanpa or Snow-land both of which names are used by the old Chinese travelers.2 Gergan and Hassnain, note that the Chinese annals speak of “Great and little Poliu”; from this we infer the names of “Great
and little Tibet”. This name is also found in the works of the later Kashmiri historians. Persian language sources of the Mughal period generally use the terms Tibet-i-Kalan or Tibet-i-Buzur (Great Tibet) for Ladakh andTibet-i-Khurd, (Little Tibet) for Baltistan writes Jigar Mohammed.3
Of all the names designated for Ladakh, I believe the ‘Land of High Passes’ is the most appropriate. Jacqueline Fewkes also states that, it is the direct translation of the word ‘Ladags’ itself, as ‘la’ means ‘pass’ and ‘dags’ means ‘land’. The naming of the region after the many passes that provide ways through in the surrounding mountains refers to the importance of conceptualizing the Ladakhi region as a busy conduit for movement of people between regions, rather than an isolated mountain region. Much of the movement has historically been concerned with trade between Central Asia and Ladakh and onwards to Kashmir and beyond.4 Today Ladakh might seem to be an isolated country. To the 18th -19th century writers Ladakh stands for an isolated and backward region. Contrarily for much of its history, especially during the 16th to 19th centuries, it was the nodal point of a complex labyrinth of trade routes. Leh, the capital of Ladakh was a trading entrepot, and it served as a transit camp where all preparations were made for the onward journey to Tibet or Central Asia.5
Structure and stratification of society:
In analysing the structure and the composition of society, we get the idea of a hierarchical structure and composition of society comprising of at least three distinct peoples, the Dards, the Mons and the Tibetan Mongoloid. The La-dvags-Rgyal-rabs and the oral tradition of Ladakh, the folk songs and folk loreetc support this fact. From the Ladakhi folk songs and folk lore, the division of society can be understood, and it can be said that the population was categorised into a very large common layer and a very small upper and lower layers. FrenandaPerie, has accounted the Upper high Class that is the king and the aristocrats known as Skudrakconstituting less than five percentage of the population. Below them in the hierarchy, existed the large layer of commoners called as the Mimangs, and at the bottom were the lower caste known as Rigsngan which make up only around 10 percent of the total population.6
The social division of Ladakh can be understood through the folklores and the folk songs that show the important social hierarchies. The folk songs and folklores reflect the socio-political structure of Ladakhi society during the time of their composition. In many folk songs of Ladakh, this hierarchy in the society is significant, these song has been passed orally from generation to generation. One such song is the:
Today the stars are shining in the sky,
Today the sunrays are moving the earth,
Today the Lama, and the three jewels are high,
Today the minister’s courage is high,
Today the parents are on the best agreement,
Today the people are happy.7
Another such folksong from Ladakh collected by Franke also reflects the hierarchy in society. This song is from the Ancient Epic of Ladakh GyalemKesar8:
Thou host of the heaven, come to the fight,
And WangboGyabzhin be at thy head!
Thou host of the earth, come to the fight,
And mother Skyabdun be at thy head!
Thou host of the waters, come to the fight,
The water king Ljogpo be at thy head!
At the head of the heroes, of Ling, Palle must stride;
At the head of the women of the Ling, Astag must ride!
At the head of the Lamas of Ling,Tsegu must ride;
At the head of the Mons of Ling, Penag must stride!
At the head of the smiths of Ling, Karog shall ride;
At the head of the Bhedas of Ling,Kangrings shall stride !......... so on..9
The above songs reflect that, the society followed a hierarchical structure. The lamas were put at top stratum of society followed by the king and the aristocrats that is the nobility and then the mass of commoners. The lower caste or the ‘rigdngyan’ has been mentioned which shows that they were also included in the hierarchy but considered as outcastes. In Ladakh the social hierarchy was more obvious in the titles of address and reference and also from the order of sitting in the social gatherings.
The British Joint Commissioner of Ladakh, Captain Ramsay, has classified the castes in Ladakh with its different divisions and subdivisions. According to him, there were five great classes or castes, each of which is termed as ‘riks’10 the subdivision of these Five classes were called ‘roospa’. The following table has been drawn by Ramsay to show the different classes and their principal subdivisions.
1. The first class or ‘rigal-riks’ consisted only of royal personages.
2. The second class or ‘trangzey-riks’ comprised of priest of the different sects. Among lamas no caste are recognized, all lamas in virtue of their priestly calling rank next to the royal caste.
3. The third class or ‘rjey-riks’ consisted of the upper class officials.
4. The fourth class or ‘hmang-riks’ consisted of Zamindars in the general.
5. The fifth class or ‘tolbey-riks’ comprised of artisans, musicians, dancers and jugglers.11
|
Class 1 |
Class 2 |
Class 3 |
Class 4 |
Class 5 |
|
Rgailriks |
Trangzeyriks |
Rjeyriks |
Hmangriks |
Tolbeyriks |
|
SUB DIVISION |
SUB DIVISIONS. Red cap sects. |
SUB DIVISIONS |
SUB DIVISIONS |
SUB DIVISIONS |
|
NONE |
Rnikmapa |
Cho |
Nangso (King’s treasurer) |
Zospon (officer of artisans) |
|
Urgianpa |
Kalon |
Chakzot (steward) |
Zopa (artisan) |
|
|
Saskiapa |
Lonpo |
Ngierpa (store keeper) |
Sarzopa (goldsmith) |
|
|
Kargioopa |
Lardak |
Chhakshi (King’s domestics) |
Mulzopa (Silversmith) |
|
|
Skarmapa |
|
Ghopa (doorkeeper) |
Zangszopa (coopersmith) |
|
|
|
Drogongpa |
Togochey (Lambardar) |
Lchakzopa or gara (blacksmith) |
|
|
|
Staglungpa |
Trongspon (assistant lambardar) |
Shingkhan (Carpenter) |
|
|
|
Hlondrukpa |
Choonpa (the waterer of the king’s field) |
Rtsikspon (builder) |
|
|
|
YELLOW CAP SECT |
Rardzi (goatherd) |
Koszopa or Kostsem khan (tailor) |
|
|
|
Geylukspa or Ghulanpa |
|
Bardzi (cowherd) |
Mon (musician) |
|
|
|
|
Thralpa (cooly) |
Hlamkhan (shoemaker) |
|
|
|
|
Khirdzi (dogkeeper) |
Beyda (Musician) |
|
|
|
|
Malakhan (juggler) |
Source: Captain H. Ramsay, Western Tibet: Ractical Dictionary of the Language and Customs of the Districts included in the Ladakh Wazarat, 1890, Lahore, pp 26-27
Scholars like Ferry Erdmann, have described the social hierarchy in Ladakh in terms of an arranged the social layer into fourfold division i.ergyalrigs (royalty), skudrags (nobility), dmangsrigs (commoners), and rigsnangs (outcast).12 About the king of Ladakh, Fernanda Pirie, says that the Ladakhi King appears to have developed an authority that was a mixture of the divine (claimed descent from the gods, a limited ritual role and patronage of the monasteries) and the moral and contractual (their response to the needs of their subjects, assumption of obligations towards them and justness of their rule).13
H. N. Kaul also asserts these hierarchical social structure and writes that Ladakhi society followed a certain hierarchical order in which the King or the Gyalpo and his decedents occupies the top position in this social strata. Next in the order were the aristocrats who held high ranks like the Kalon (prime minister), Lonpo (noblility), and Kharpons, and were economically far better than the mass common people. Next were the people who were wealthy and known but were not from the aristocratic clan. At the base of this order were the farmers, artisans and the labouring class in general. Beyond this order were certain people who were considered outcaste, who in Ladakh were known as Rigsngan:Mons, Bedas, and the Garas, who were the carpenters, musicians and the blacksmiths.
Along with this hierarchical structure, we must not forget about the parallel system of power and authority that is secular and religious, which are connected in certain ways but have always remained distinct. Therefore, in this structure of society, the monks or the Lamas or the reincarnate of great Buddhist Lamas that is the Kushoks, Rinpochesetc, in spite of born in any class fall under a different category.14
Rann Singh Mann writes that, in certain aspects the order of ranking resembles the caste system of mainland India, but certain features typical of caste system is missing in the community of Ladakh.15 However, we cannot neglect the presence of caste system in the Ladakhi society but it can be said that it was not as much rigid as the caste system of the mainland India. The lower caste of Ladakh, that is the Bedas, Mons, Garas were allowed to offer their prayers in the same monasteries as that of the other caste. And there seems to be no restriction on their movements in any house which shows that the feeling of pollution did not exist. But like in the caste system they have occupational specialisation like the mons were carpenters, bedas being the drummers or the musicians and the Garas were the blacksmiths. The lower caste in Ladakh was arranged in a social hierarchy each occupying a definite rung of social ladder. This lower caste person observes endogamy, and in normal circumstances not permitted for intermarrying. In addition, Petech writes about the increase in the hereditary character of the society during the time of King Nima Namgyal.16
The social status is expressed in many aspects of behaviour, and social hierarchy is most obvious in titles of reference and address. For instance the nobility are addressed with words such as ‘Kaga’, ‘Nono’, ‘Shema’ and ‘Chocho’ which are honorific language. Erdmann have also noticed the order of hierarchy on the order of seat at the gatherings, as well as in the heights of tables and cups, and in the quality of furniture, padding, tapestry, and all kinds of utensils. In every celebration be it in houses or in tents, people sitting position is regulated by the principle of order according to a linear disposition. The line of sitting people – tal (gral) – (that can continue from a straight line to an ‘L’ shape) has at its head the most important members and the first seat in this line, it is reserved to the most highly respected person. This seat is called talgo(gral-mgo), meaning onset of the line. At the end of the tal, would be the closet to the entrance door and is the least important seat and is called khym-mjug meaning house end.17 The low tables-cogtse (cok-tse) placed in front of the guest seats also embody the hierarchy of the sitting order. Cogtse are higher the more important the guest, decreasing in height towards the guest at the end of the tal. Therefore humans are ‘ordered’ inside the house (byan-sa) according to the relationship between spatial disposition-tal(gral_ and obeject –cogtse. Even in the pattern of houses the difference are quite noticeable, the nobility have the exclusive right to have balconies on their houses and other decorations.18
Monasteries and the monastic organization:
Along with this hierarchical structure, one must also understand the dual system of power and authority, secular and religious, whose two strands were in many respects interconnected but remained distinct. Along with the mildly despotic rule of the king and the nobility, monasteries represented distinct centres of power, based upon the religious authority of their monks and reincarnate lamas. One important characterising feature of Ladakh is the existence of monasteries, which has existed over centuries with a very close and intimate bearing on the life and culture of the people of Ladakh.
The monasteries are the largest landholders in Ladakh, and thus influenced the economic life of it. The monasteries being economically sound and surplus, advance loans to the needy. Almost every village has a monastery, and these monasteries have existed over centuries with a close and intimate bearing on the life and culture of the people embracing Buddhist faith. These monastic establishments were quite rich and controlled important portions of the wealth of Ladakh. From early times the kings had made numerous grants of lands to the monasteries, and some, like Hemis, the monastery of the royal house held extensive properties.19
According to Cunningham, the estimate of the revenue of Ladakh before the Dogra Conquest, 4000 households out of a total of 24,000 were assigned to the monasteries.20 The land of the monasteries were cultivated by the working lamas and often these were given to farmers on metayer basis, that is the tillers handed over half the produce to the monasteries and were exempted from taxation and begar or free carriage.21 In order to maintain the large establishment of monks and pay the expenses of ceremonials, these monasteries had various avenues of income. Its own endowment lands were the primary source of income.22 It received alms from the laity and also received a good income by engaging in trade, and advancing money and grain on loan to the laity.
As far as the economic function goes, the role of the monastery in the economy of Ladakh is still significant. Monasteries own fertile lands in villages and, to a large extent, control and operate the economy of the territory through ownership of land and through exploitation of its resources. What G. Tucci has stated for Tibet monasteries is also applicable for monasteries in Ladakh, as in Tibet the Ladakhi monasteries possessed economic resources including land, animal, and laborers from which a major portion of the monk’s subsistence and monastic expenses derived.23 Monasteries have received donation of land from rulers and village families over many generations. So the land belonging to the monastery is widely scattered in many localities or villages. The dwellers of these localities or villages work on the land either as tenants or as agricultural labourers. The tenants pay some percentage of the produce to the monastery. According to Harjit Singh, “The tenants pay 1/5 to 1/2 of the produce to the monastery as rent”24. The monastery being economically sound and having a surplus advances loans to the needy people. Generally, the loan is in kind in the form of wheat, barley, etc. These articles are borrowed for a specific period and they are then returned with some addition to the borrowed quantity. According to TseringShakya, Loans are made to farmers against interest which can be considerable. In the past, in Tibet and in the Himalaya generally, such debts have been crippling but there has been a steady reduction in this burden on villagers.25
The sources of the monastery are:
1. Interest from the money and articles lending operation.
2. Donations collected for particular liturgical events by the gnyer-pa (steward) assigned to event specific responsibilities26.
3. Donations and offerings made by the general population.
4. Trade carried out by major monasteries.27
5. Much of these incomes are provided in the form of wheat, barley, barley flour and butter.
Monastic recruitment, Hierarchy and Administration:
In Ladakh and in Tibet, monks were almost recruited as very young children through the agency of their parents and guardians. Monks were brought to the monastery as a young boys usually between the ages of 6-12, it was not considered important what these boys themselves felt about a lifetime commitment to celibate monasticism and they were basically made monks without regard to their personality, temperament or inclination28. There were many reasons why parents made a son a monk. First making son monk was culturally valued, even if the boy never became a great religious thinker or practitioner. Just his presence in a monastery would benefit him in this and future lives. It was, therefore, a way of giving a son a prestigious status which required little of the hard manual labor that permeated village life, at the same time it created positive “merit” for the parents. There is saying that making a son a monk is considered equivalent to building a stupa in terms of merit gained.29 There are also other motivations for enrolling one’s son as derived from the divination of lamas or monks. Parents frequently sought divination when their children were ill. Sometimes the remedy prescribed by the practitioner involved propitiating some god who was causing the illness but on other occasions, the prescription called for the parents to promise to later dedicate this boy to religion to a monastic life. Other situation may occur when a young boy showed a liking for monks. And another reason which is common, occurs when parents made a son a monk as a part of a strategy for organizing their family’s human resources so as to minimize the likelihood of family fragmentation and land division in the next generation.30
There are several stages of monkhood. The first stage is when a boy enters the monastery as a novice monk.31 Then he enters the next stage called dgetshul (novice monk stage), the commencing of monkhood but not quite fully ordained monk. He is expected to participate in the daily prayers and to perform duties of the monasteries. The novice monk may continue to study under a senior monk of the monastery. After the completion of novice monk’s stage, the monk will be eligible for entering the rank of a fully ordained monk, the dgeslong.32. The ordained monk takes his vows in the presence of the entire monastic community in the main temple. The dgeslong is the fully ordained monk. As such, he is entitled to be called Lama, although the title is used in courtesy for almost all monks in Ladakh. He is eligible for the various offices and services in which he contributes to the administration of the monastery as a whole. The highest degree of the monastic education is thedgebshes, equivalent to the doctorate degree of the modern education system. In addition to the above categories, there are some other sacred specialists. Like Lamas, the nuns (Jo mo) have also been categorized. A novice nun is termed as dgebsnyen ma. On the next promotion, she becomes dgetshul ma and then dgeslong ma.33
The appointment of an ordained monk to the various offices of a monastery is a remarkably democratic system. The governing body of the monastery is in-fact the collective assembly of monks, which meets regularly to discuss questions of the day, to make policy and to appoint officers. The opinion of older monks are given due weight in the major decisions of the entire monkhood. Usually the officers are appointed for a period of two or three years, depending on the monastery. One can also be re-elected to the same post for more years and also get elected to various other posts in the monastery. Thus, every senior monk has a wide experience of the main offices and monastic affairs. According to John Crook and TseringShakya, “the system drives from the code of governance in the Vinaya: the earliest regulation of a community.”34
There is a well-organized administrative system in every monastery in Ladakh. In most of the major monasteries there, an incarnate lama, called in Ladakhi and Tibetan ‘Rinpochey’, occupies the highest post. The monastic administrative ranks in Ladakh are as follows:
· Khenpo (mkhanpo) = Abbot
· Lobon (slob dpon) = Teacher
· Umzat (dbumdzad) = Master of Ceremonies
· Uchung (dbuchung) = Deputy Master of Ceremonies
· Gesko (dgebskos) = Disciplinarian
· Chagzot (phyagmdzod) = Treasurer
Each of the major monasteries in Ladakh is supported by nearby villages. Some of the monasteries also have villages very far from the monastery affiliated to it. For example Hemis monastery has the support of many villages in all parts of Ladakh. The number of villages that support a monastery is largely dependent on the size of the monastery. The bigger monasteries like Lamayuru, Spituk and Hemis have the support of many villages than the smaller monasteries.35 Monasteries are essentially religious establishments catering to the religious and spiritual needs of the people. Besides their contribution in the field of education, their role in cultural and social needs of the people is no less significant. The monks provide religious services to the village and additionally produce religious objects. Most of the village houses are filled with Buddhist religious objects and symbols. A family chapel can be found in most houses. It is often the most elaborate and expensive part of the house and filled with religious texts, rugs, thangkas and other treasures passed on from generation to generation. The monks and nuns are invited by individual families and also to villages for village ceremonies and the recitation of important Buddhist texts. Usually a family invites monks and nuns and even laymen36, to recite the ‘Bum, the Prajnaparamita in 100,000 lines, the Heart Sutra37. This text consists of sixteen volumes and most families can afford the recitation of this text by the clergy. The monks get food and money for their services. The recitation of Kanjur (collection of Buddhist texts), consisting of one hundred and eight volumes, takes place at the village level.
The monastery not only plays an important role in the religious and spiritual life of the people in Ladakh but also in their social functions. Lama interaction is important in every major Buddhist social function in Ladakh. On the occasions of birth, marriage and death, monks are consulted and invited to perform prayers. When a child is born, the parents visit with the child the head Lama and request him to suggest a name for their child. An auspicious day for a marriage is suggested by the local astrologer (dbonpo) or by a monk. On the occasion of the marriage, monks perform worship at both the bride and groom’s houses. In the event of death in a family, the monk performs the ‘pho ba ritual before anyone else touches the dead body. The ritual is believed to pave the way for a smooth heavenly journey, and for a better rebirth. Monks are invited for cremation, and after the cremation is over, monks continue to perform worship for more days in the house of the dead.
Taxation system in Ladakh:
In Ladakh the word khralis used for the tax, tribute, duty and labour obligation. Tax was paid in kind or in the form of labour obligation. To understand the system of taxation in Ladakh we need to first understand the pattern of household in Ladakhi society. Nicky Grist has discussed about the household pattern in Ladakh and its role in the taxation and ownership of the land. Ladakhi society was divided during the period under king’s rule as it is now, into various rigs and status groups according to the household pattern.
The source of revenue (thobtang) were taxes and custom duties. The most important item of the revenue was a tax on property, levied as a rule on houses and not on tilled land. The monasteries and crown villages were exempted from this tax. Real property was held by royal grant, evidenced by documents (kasog) issued by the king. This was the only legal evidence allowed, if the document was lost or destroyed, since there were no copies preserved at the capital, a fresh one had to be applied for, the application being investigated and certified by the elders.38 The unity of the taxation was the house or firehead (thabka). The tax on houses was collected partly in kind, i.e. in barley (brukral) and partly in silver, minted or not (dnulkral). The poorer classes are exempted from the house-tax, but were subjected to labour service (ulag).39 As per Gergan, before 1683 the king levied also a tax in gold (gserkral) amounting to ten goats-loads of gold dust yearly, Spiti and Lahul paid a tribute in iron bars. Since in Ladakh transit trade was of great importance, customs duties (sogam) imposed both on imports and exports, represented a large source of revenue.40 Alexander Cunningham, has listed the gross revenue of the king of Ladakh during the last years of independence,41
|
House-tax |
Rs. 30,000 |
|
Tax on brokers |
Rs 5,700 |
|
Presents or fees |
Rs 5,000 |
|
Customs |
Rs, 18,000 |
Source: Alexander Cunningham, Ladakh: Physical, Statistical and Historical, 1997, Srinagar, Gulshan Publisher, p. 271.
In Ladakh the people are usually known through their household name since historical times, through the study of continuity of these household system we will get the idea about the structure of village and the society as whole during the period of our study. In Ladakhi society the importance of a household, Khangba inLadakhi, as the basic unit of village organisation is essential. Fernanda Perie asserting the importance of households writes, “khangba is the basic unit of village organisation, all non-communal land, livestock, agriculture and households goods are owned by the Khangba and water rights and village obligations are allocated amongst them”.42 So it can be said that a person has to be a member of this household that is either by birth or by marriage, to become a member of the village.
It is seen that according to the household pattern, the society has been divided into status or what in Ladakhi is called Rigs. In Ladakhi Village, households were organised into main houses ‘ khangchen’, where the head of the family live, and subsidiary houses ‘khangchung’ inhabited by older relatives and other dependents and have a little of family’s land called the maskal when it is granted to mother andphaskal for the elderly father. Thetronpa households in Ladakh held land on which they had rights from the king and passed this land down with the house and because of which they were government taxpayers. The tax was levied on tronpakhangchens, which is the main house, which holds most of the family’s land, and it was khangchens, which had to make annual payments sa-Khralland tax to the state. These were paid in grain called Dru-thral and in money called mul-thral. These taxes in money and kind were levied according to the size of land holding of a house. In addition, when the need arose, households had to provide workers for public works such as the construction of irrigation canals, roads and bridges as well as making special donations, voluntary or otherwise for such works. Under the kings of Ladakh and most of the time under the Dograskhanchun or nagchun, were completely exempt from these taxes.
The Ladakhi economy depended on the combination of agriculture, pastoralism and trade. Therefore, in an economy that was only partly monetised, the most important taxes were in labour and kind. Moorcroft writes, “They pay no money to the state, but are bound to suit and service both domestic and military and furnish contributions in kind for the support of the Raja and the governors of districts”.43 He further gives us information about how certain areas provides other provisions instead of these taxes, in the form of fuel, milk, butter, tea, etc for the royal family, official visitors and other officials. He writes, “Thus the inhabitants of the country about Leh supply the raja with the fuel, milk, butter, tea, and grass for his cattle, servants for his person and labourers for his fields”.44 Households not only paid a tax to the government they also give an annual donation called sodnyomps or alms of about two khals of grains to one or more monasteries.45
The taxes which has to be paid in kind and cash, was levied according to the size of the landholding of the household. Meer IzzatUllah, says that in the early 19th century tax was paid by each proprietor in proportion to the amount of land held by him but the land is not measured but determined by water advantages. Some are assessed as having enough for one flourmill, for half a flour mill or for land for so many days ploughing etc.46 About the water rights and taxation system, Corinne Wacker, says that the state allocated the water rights in Ladakh and prior to 1842, Ladakhi families were given the right to built an irrigation canal by the king, and accordingly the household taxation was related to the water used.47 It seems that the taxation officer used to record the land property and irrigation perimeter on a silk cloth to identify the taxes to be paid in the villages. After the Dogra conquest of Ladakh, Khushi Mohammad, the officer responsible for Ladakh (1902-1905), copied the royal water and land register and its silk maps on to a record known as the Bandobast.48
About the Bandobast system H.N. Kaul writes, “The Bandobastwas related to a tax and settlement reform, which aimed at supporting the long-distance Central Asian trade through Ladakh. Under this system, villages in Ladakh had to contribute obligatory labour as porter and provide animal transport to sustain the caravan economy”.49 The Bandobastindicates that water rights are held by the ‘houses’, a tax unit, known also in Tibet which includes the joint family, a mainhouse and several auxiliary smaller dwellings.50 The land property is registered in canal and marlaunits. One canal corresponds to twenty marlaand eight canals correspond to one acre or to 0.4 hectares of land.
Corvee labour, oru’lag or the Begar:
Another important historical tax system was the obligatory or corveelabour, which was an intrinsic part of the tax system not only in Ladakh but also in Tibet, Kashmir, and throughout the Himalayan states. John Bray writes that the obligatory labour included work that was communal benefit like the repairs of bridges, roads, and monasteries, as well as the carriage of goods for senior political and religious figures. In Ladakh corvee was known by different names at various times, like beggar, res, u’lagorthral.51 Nicola Grist also highlighting the political and ritual aspects of corvee, says that at the local level, transport beggar was partly an enactment of the social and regional hierarchy, and at the state level, Ladakh and Tibet recognised mutual obligations to provide transport labour for key missions (Lopchak and Chapa) travelling between their territories. She further argues that the beggar provided a mechanism by which they implicitly recognised each other’s legitimacy and status.52 Beggar or the corvee system can be understood as a form of land tax, and which according to Captain Ramsay, in Ladakh the transport obligation fell specifically on the Khangchens.53 Under the Begar system the villagers had to transport wood and other supplies to Leh and also act as portal runners.54 Villagers also provide beggar transport for the king as well as senior officials, monks and traders.
The two missions ofLopchak and Chapa benefited from the corvee or Begar transport. According to the ‘Treaty of Temisgham’ 1684,55 Ladakh agreed to send a mission to Tibet with some sets of gifts every three year, and it also in reciprocity will get the Chapa mission from Tibet every year. These two missions had its political and religious significance along with the important commercial role. John Bary also argues that both the missions were benefited by the corvee transport which consisted of 260 baggage animals plus riding animals on either side of the border, thus proving the profitability of the mission.56
After 1842 when Ladakh lost her final Independence and came under Kashmir according to the treaty of Amritsar, which made Gulab Singh the Maharaja of Kashmir. The Dogra administration was a source of considerable hardship for ordinary villagers.Gulab Singh government used the Begar system to gain more economic gains and oppressed the people, and took over the king’s trading role as well as his rights of Begar. Describing the Dogra rule of Ladakh, John Bray writes, “The Dogra invasion marks one of the most important turning points in Ladakhi history in that it bound the region once and for all to a South Asian polity rather than to Tibet or Central Asia”.57 By 1867, British government have appointed a British officer on special duty in Leh, and by 1870 the British signed a formal agreement with Ranbir Singh providing for the appointment of a British Joint Commissioner in Leh as a permanent basis. After the death of Maharaja Ranbir Singh in 1885, the British Intervention in the Kashmir affairs increased considerably, one main reason might have been their concern about the security of India’s northern frontier in the light of Russian expansion in Central Asia58.
The British officials have provided different views on Begar in Ladakh many have argued for the abolition of the system as being burdensome on the villagers. Captain Ramsay, the British Joint Commissioner of Ladakh from 1885 -1891, described Begar as a ‘vicious system’, and further argued that Ladakhis objected to it more than anything else in the Dogra administration.59 Like Ramsay another British Joint Commissioner Captain R. L. Kennion, also argued for the abolition of beggar as beggar system was too burden for the local villagers. The higher British officials however were of the view that the system has been existed in the area from time immemorial and cannot be changed suddenly but with gradual reforms only. In a letter written by Sir Adelbert Talbot, the Resident in Kashmir to the Government of India, the difficulties of reforming the system has been emphasised:
To Western ideas the system of Kar beggar is very repugnant but it must be remembered that it has existed in these frontier countries from the time immemorial, and that the utmost we can expect to do is to minimise the hardships of free labour by giving the people some form of compensation, for there is little chance that coolies can be dispensed with until roads are put into much better order than they are now.60
The final stage in the official regulation of Begar came with the revenue settlement in 1908 and 1909, conducted by the wazir of Ladakh ChaudhriKhushi Mohammad. The overall policy was that the government should retain its established right to Begar but that begarisshould be paid according to a set rate. This system of revised transport labour or beggar remained in force until shortly after independence.
Some the sources we find beggar system as burdensome for the villagers even though it was a mark of status of a household. During 1821-1822, when Moorcroft and Trebeck was in Dras they witnessed the villagers suffering badly because of the beggar system. There are also instances of local official taking advantage of the system for their own benefit and one such example has been provided by Moorcroft and Trebeck. According to them the Dras village was the joint property of the king of Ladakh and the malik of neighbouring part of Kashmir (no specific name has been given). He further writes,
“The nuna (nono) Khalun was at Dras when i arrived for the purpose of building a fort, and, whilst in the district, had exacted fifty sheep, besides a large quantity of butter, milk and firewood, for the use of himself and his attendants. The visits of the Malik are equally costly, and the people are further liable to be pressed as porters and labourers for either land-lord, not only for their personal service, but for that of all travellers and merchants, for the pecuniary profit of their superior. In a year of brisk traffic this has been known to amount to about fifteen thousand pounds, of which the Chamal, or head farmer, and the Karpun, or local governor, manage to pocket about one third, transmitting the remainder, inequal portions, to the Raja and the Malik, the poor peasants receiving no compensation whatever for their labour, loss of time and injury to their own lands”.61
CONCLUSION:
In studying the social composition of Ladakh society we find the blending to three races, the Dards, the Mons and the Tibetan Mongoloid. These three races met and mingled into a new community with its own characteristics. The society is centred on a hierarchical structure in which the aristocrats occupies the top position, followed by the nobility. Next in the social order were common people. Beyond this order were the “Rigsngan” who holds the lowest stratum in this social order. Along with this hierarchical structure, the monasteries of Ladakh were centres of powers which influenced all aspects of the society. Monasteries played important role in the religious, and spiritual life of the people as well in their social functions.
The economy of Ladakh depended on the combination of agriculture, pastoralism and trade. The taxes were paid in the kind or in the form of labour obligation. The tax was levied according to the household system, in which the Tronpakhangchen, which is the main house holding most of the family’s land had to pay these tax. Under the Dogras the Bandobast system was introduced aiming for the more profits from the long distance trade by using or rather exploiting the obligatory labour system. People of Ladakh had to provide beggar transport for the kings as well as senior officials, monks and traders. The system was very burdensome for the people of Ladakh. Even though some British Joint Commissioners stationed at Leh tried to abolish it, but it continued till the later period.
REFERENCE:
1. Maryul or Marpoyul, “Red Land”, Csoma de Koros spells the name Maryul the “low Country”, but Hwang Tsang in A.D. 640, calls it Malopho or Marpo that is “Red”, there is still some doubt about the true meaning of the name.
2. Alexander Cunningham, Ladakh Physical, Statistical and Historical, 1997, Kashmir, Gulshan Publishers, p. 19.
3. Jigar Mohammed, ‘Mughal Sources on Medieval Ladakh, Baltistan and Western Tibet’, in Ladakh Historiesedt. John Bray, Brills, 2005, p.148. Mirza Haider, Tarikh-iRashidi, AbulFazl in Akbarnama, Inayat Khan in Shahjahan Nama, Bernier in his travelogue, mention Ladakh as Great Tibet or Tibet-i-Kalan. Even later Urdu language writers such as Hashmatullah also have used the same terminology.
4. Jacqueline Fewkes, Trade and Contemporary Society along the Silk Road: An ethno-history of Ladakh, Routledge, 2009, p. 21.
5. Abdul Ghani Sheikh, Reflection on Ladakh, Tibet and Central Asia, Skyline Publication, New Delhi, 2010, p. 28.
6. FrenandaPerie, Peace and conflict in Ladakh, the construction of a Fragile web of order, Brills, Boston, 2007, p. 27.
7. The song has been taken from Erdmann’s article. Ferry, Erdmann, ‘Social Stratification in Ladakh: Upper Estates and Lower Caste’, Recent Research on Ladakh, p. 141.
8. Gesar Epic is a story of King Gesarwhich dates from the 12th century. In Ladakh the singers and story tellers maintain the oral tradition and has been passed on to the successive generation.
9. Song has been taken from A. H. Franke, A History of Ladakh, Sterling Publishers, New Delhi, 1977, p. 78.
10. The word ‘Rigs’, in Ladakh means, caste, class or rank and has been used by A. H. Jaschke, ATibetan- English Dictionary, 1181, reprinted London: Routledge and Kegan P aul, 1977, p. 527.
11. Captain H. Ramsay, Western Tibet: Ractical Dictionary of the Language and Customs of the Districts included in Ladakh Wazarat, W. Ball and co, Lahore, 1890, pp. 26-27.
12. Ferry Erdmann, ‘Social Stratification in Ladakh: Upper estates and Low-Caste’, Recent Research on Ladakh, p.141.
13. Fernanda Perie, Peace and conflict in Ladakh, the construction of a Fragile web of order, Brills, Boston, 2007, p. 27.
14. H. N. Kaul, Rediscovery of Ladakh, Indus Publishing House, New Delhi, 1998, p. 132.
15. Rann Mann Singh, Ladakh Then and Now, Ecological and Political, Mittal Publication, New Delhi, 2012, p. 48.
16. Luciano Petech, The kingdom of Ladakh: c. 950-1842 A.D., p. 93.
17. Edoardo Paolo Ferrai, A Fading Legacy: Ladakh’s Vernacular Architecture, Dissertation at University of the Studies of Forence, p. 102.
18. Ferry Erdmann, ‘Social Stratification in Ladakh: Upper estates and Low-Caste’, Recent Research on Ladakh, pp. 148-149.
19. A.H. Franke, Antiquities of IndianTibet, p. 109; Seven Hedin, Trans- Himalaya: Discoveries and Adventures in Tibet, p. 63.
20. Alexander Cunningham, Ladakh: Physical, Statistical and Historical, p. 270.
21. E. F. Knight, Where Three Empires Meet, Longmans, London, 1895, p. 200.
22. Thomas Thomson, Western Himalaya and Tibet; A Narrative of a Journey through the Mountains of Northern India, During the years 1847-8, Reeve & Co., London, 1852, p. 185.
23. G. Tucci. The Religion of Tibet, University of California Press, New York, 1980, p. 9.
24. C. L. Datta, Ladakh and Western Himalayan Politics: 1819-1948, MunshiramManoharlal Publishers, New Delhi, 1973, p. 19.
25. Frederic Drew, The Northern Barrier of India, Light and Life Publishers, Jammu, 1971, p. 287.
26. Alexander Cunningham, Ladakh: Physical, Statistical and Historical, p. 238.
27. Frederic Drew, The Northern Barrier of India, p. 287.
28. Melvyn C, Goldstein, ‘Tibetan Buddhism and Mass Monasticism’, in Des moines et des monialesdans le monde, La vie monastiquedans le miroir de la parente, edt. Adline Herron & Gisele Krauskophh, Presses Universitaires de Toulouse le Mirail, 2010, p .4. www.case.edu/affil/tibet/booksAndPapers/buddhistmonasticism
29. Ibid., p. 7.
30. Ibid., p. 8.
31. John Crook and TseringShakya, Himalayan Buddhist villages, Environment, Resources, Society and Religious Life in Zangskar Ladakh, MotilalBanarsidas, Delhi, 1994, p. 580.
32. Ibid.
33. There were only few nunneries in Ladakh, which were never considered important enough to attract the interest of historians and writers, almost no major works or studies has been done on nunneries. Whatever small written documents we have, they all are focused on the main monasteries. Nun as compared to the Buddhist monks are regarded as lower in hierarchy of monastery, I have never came across a nun being the head of any monastery in Ladakh.
34. John Crook and TseringShakya, Himalayan Buddhist villages, p. 581.
35. SonamJoldan, Ladakh Traditional ties with Buddhist Tibet, Gyan Books, New Delhi, 2012, p. 73.
36. Usually a Buddhist men who can read the religious text.
37. John Crook and TseringShakya, Himalayan Buddhist villages, p. 581.
38. Luciano Petech, The Kingdom of Ladakh: c. 950-1842 A.D., p. 158; S. Gergan, La dvagsryalrabs chi myedster, p. 616.
39. Ibid.
40. S. S. Gergan, La dvagsgyalrabs chi myedster, p. 604.
41. Alexander Cunningham, Ladakh: Physical, Statistical and Historical, p. 271.
42. Fernanda Perie, Peace and conflict in Ladakh, the construction of a Fragile web of order, Brills, Boston, 2007, p. 45.
43. Willam Moorcroft and George Trebeck, Travels in Himalayan Provinces of Hindustan and Punjab, vol. 1, Asian Educational Services, Delhi, 1989, p. 320.
44. Ibid., p. 320.
45. Nicky Grist, ‘Land tax, Labour and household organisation in Ladakh’, Recenct Research on Ladakh,p. 131.
46. H. H. Wilson: 'Travels Beyond the Himalaya by Mir IzzetUllah', Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society, Vol. VII, 1843, p. 11.
47. Corinne Wacker, ‘Can Irrigation systems disclose the History of the Villages in Ladakh? The example of Tagmachig’, Recent Research on Ladakh, 2007, p. 5.
48. Ibid., p. 6.
49. Ibid., p. 7..
50. Pedro Carrasco, ‘Land and Polity in Tibet’, Monograph 32, The American Ethnological Society, University of Washington Press, Seattle, 1959.
51. John Bray, Corvee Transport Labour in 19th and early 20th Century Ladakh: A study in Continuity and Change, Brills, Leiden, 2008, p. 43.
52. Nicola Grist, ‘The Use of obligatory Labour for Porterage in Pre-independence Ladakh’, Tibetan Studies, edt., P. Kvaerne, in Proceedings of the 6th seminar of the International Association of Tibetan Studies.
53. H. Ramsay, Western Tibet: A political History, Potala Publication, New York, 1967, pp. 78-79.
54. Ibid., p. 78.
55. The Treaty of Timisgham will be discussed in detail in the next chapter dealing mainly on Tibet.
56. John Bray, Corvee Transport Labour in 19th and Early 20th Century Ladakh: A study in Continuity and Change, p. 47.
57. Ibid., p. 48.
58. Ibid., p. 47.
59. H. Ramsay, Western Tibet: A political history. p. 47.
60. Talbot To Government of India Foreign Department, 31 May 1900. OIOC L/P&S/7/125.
61. Willaim Moorcroft and George Trebeck, Travels in Himalayan Provinces of Hindustan and the Punjab, in Ladakh and Kashmir, in Peshawar, Kabul, Kunduz and Bokhara. Edited by H. H. Wilson, vol 2, John Murray, London, 1837, pp. 41-42.
Received on 08.06.2018 Modified on 05.07.2018
Accepted on 19.07.2018 © A&V Publication all right reserved
Int. J. Rev. and Res. Social Sci. 2018; 6(3): 229-237 .
DOI: 10.5958/2454-2687.2018.00020.5